Teaching & LearningOpen Access

A new pedagogical approach to peer review of teaching in higher education

Matthew Harper, Sally Patfield, Jennifer M. Gore, Elena Prieto
The International Journal for Academic Development
April 23, 2026

Full Abstract

In the higher education sector, peer review of teaching (PRT) is widely recognised as a productive approach to improving practice through intentional observation and feedback. However, perpetual criticism plagues PRT, including a lack of clarity about what is being reviewed, unstructured and superficial processes for analysis of practice, and feelings of mistrust and anxiety among participants. In this paper, we detail a new approach to PRT that combats these challenges by systematically attending to three domains of professional learning: substantive (content), structural (delivery), and relational (relationships). Our approach uses an evidence-based pedagogical framework, explicit steps and mechanisms for participant engagement, and reciprocal, non-hierarchical modes of interaction that foster collegiality. Drawing on interview data from academics (n = 10) at one Australian university that piloted the approach in 2024, our analysis demonstrates that embedding pedagogical substance, strengthening pedagogical process, and addressing pedagogical relations enhances the PRT experience, producing benefits for academics and the institution while mitigating adverse experiences and negative outcomes. In short, we argue that anchoring PRT in pedagogy not only overcomes common challenges and critiques but opens new possibilities for more effective implementation of academic development in the future.

Publication Details

DOI

10.1080/1360144x.2026.2655920

PubMed ID

N/A

MeSH Terms

Teaching & LearningHigher Education